Alien Enamel Pin Set vs Cheshire Cat Pin: Which to Collect
By Mondo | Published: 2026-10-31
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Alien Enamel Pin Set and the Cheshire Cat Enamel Pin on size, metal finish, and backing to decide which movie enamel pin fits your collection.
Quick answer
Choose the Alien Enamel Pin Set if you want two double-posted soft enamel pins with contrasting nickel finishes. Choose the Cheshire Cat Enamel Pin if you prefer a single, slightly smaller hard enamel pin on copper metal.
Size and format: two pins versus one
The Alien set gives you two pins, each 1.6 inches tall, while the Cheshire Cat pin is a single piece 1.5 inches wide. That extra pin in the Alien set changes how you display them: you can pair the Alien Queen and Xenomorph together or split them across two jackets or boards. The Cheshire Cat pin is a standalone focal point, so it suits a collection built around one character or a single small display area.
Metal finish and enamel type
The Alien pins use soft enamel with two different nickel finishes: shiny silver for the Alien Queen and black dyed nickel for the Xenomorph. Soft enamel typically has a slightly recessed, textured feel where the color sits below the metal ridges. The Cheshire Cat pin is hard enamel on shiny copper, which usually gives a smoother, flatter surface. Neither choice is objectively better, but the Alien set offers more visual contrast between its two pins, while the Cheshire Cat leans on a single warm copper tone.
Backing and wearability
Both options use rubber clutch backings, but the Alien pins are double posted and the Cheshire Cat pin is single posted. Double posts keep a larger or heavier pin from rotating on a bag or jacket, which is useful if you plan to wear the Alien pins on a backpack strap or thick fabric. The single post on the Cheshire Cat pin is lighter and simpler to fasten, but it may shift more on soft or stretchy materials.
Designer credit and collection angle
The Cheshire Cat pin is credited to designer Sam Wolfe Connelly, which may matter if you follow specific artists or collect pins with named design credits. The Alien set does not list a designer in the supplied catalog facts, so if artist attribution is a priority for you, that is a limitation to weigh. For sci-fi enamel pins, the Alien set covers two iconic characters in one purchase, while the Cheshire Cat is a single Alice in Wonderland pin with a clear artist link.
Key trade-offs to weigh
- Two pins vs one: The Alien set gives you two characters for display flexibility, but it also means two backings to manage and more space needed if you keep them together. The Cheshire Cat pin is a single piece that is easier to place in a small collection. Decide whether you want a pair to arrange or a single focal pin.
- Soft enamel with mixed nickel vs hard enamel on copper: Soft enamel usually has a textured, slightly recessed surface, and the Alien set adds contrast with shiny silver and black dyed nickel. Hard enamel on the Cheshire Cat pin typically feels smoother and flatter, with a consistent copper finish. Pick based on whether you prefer tactile texture and contrast or a smooth, uniform surface.
- Double post vs single post: Double posts on the Alien pins reduce spinning on bags and jackets, which is helpful for active wear. The single post on the Cheshire Cat pin is lighter and quicker to fasten but may rotate more on soft fabrics. If you wear pins on a backpack or heavy jacket, favor the double-posted Alien set.
- Named designer vs character pair: The Cheshire Cat pin has a credited designer, which can matter for artist-focused collections. The Alien set does not list a designer in the catalog facts, but it delivers two sci-fi characters in one purchase. Choose the Cheshire Cat if artist attribution is important; choose the Alien set if character coverage matters more.
Product facts at a glance
- Alien Enamel Pin Set: Each soft enamel pin measures 1.6 inches tall and is double posted with rubber clutch backings. The double posts help keep both pins stable when worn on thicker fabrics like denim or canvas.
Alien Enamel Pin Set - Alice in Wonderland – Cheshire Cat Enamel Pin: This 1.5-inch wide hard enamel pin is designed by Sam Wolfe Connelly and has a single post on shiny copper metal. The hard enamel finish and copper tone give it a smoother, warmer look that suits a focused character display.
Alice in Wonderland – Cheshire Cat Enamel Pin
Who should choose which
Best for
- Collectors who want two sci-fi enamel pins with contrasting finishes and secure double-post backing
- Fans of the Alien franchise building a themed board or jacket
- Buyers who prefer soft enamel texture and mixed metal tones
Not for
- Shoppers who want a single pin with a credited designer
- Collectors who prefer a smooth hard enamel surface on a warm copper tone
- Anyone looking for a one-pin purchase with minimal backing hardware
